Hello dear
Welcome To The Pickled Herring
The Pickled Herring, located in picturesque Bayfield, WI, offers a warm and inviting atmosphere with stunning views of the water. Renowned for its attentive and hospitable staff, the restaurant caters to diverse dietary needs, including truly gluten-free options. Guests rave about the fresh, delicious cuisine, with standout items like the chili, sweet potato fries, and the indulgent Steak Naan. Mixing craft cocktails with culinary creativity, the bar impresses every visitor. Whether you're indulging in classic cheese curds or adventurous dishes like sautéed fish livers, each meal promises generous portions and an exceptional dining experience that calls for return visits.
Taste the best
Discover Our Menu
Wisconsin Poutine
US$16.99Shiner Lemonade Shandy - 4.2% Abv
Miller Lite
Mango Cart By Golden Road - 4% Abv
Bent Paddle Cosmic Lounge Hazy Ipa
New Glarus Spotted Cow
Earth Rider Superior Ale
Alaskin White Ale
Surly Furious Ipa - 6.7% Abv
About
The Pickled Herring
If you find yourself in Bayfield, Wisconsin, a culinary treasure awaits you at The Pickled Herring. Nestled at 1 Rittenhouse Ave, this inviting establishment offers a unique blend of vibrant flavors and a charming lakeside atmosphere that captures the essence of its surroundings.
Upon entering, you're greeted by a warm and hospitable staff that makes it clear your dining experience is their priority. Patrons rave about the attentive service, with numerous reviews highlighting the staff's commitment to dietary needs, particularly for those seeking gluten-free options. According to guest Joseph Conant, the team is diligent about changing gloves and ensuring meals are prepared with care, making it a haven for those with gluten sensitivities.
The menu at The Pickled Herring shines with creativity and freshness. A standout dish, the Steak Naan, not only serves as a delicious appetizer but could easily steal the spotlight as a filling entrée, as mentioned by Kaylynn Morrow. Moreover, the bar is well-stocked, offering unique cocktails that have left a lasting impression on guests, sparking a desire to recreate them at home.
For those looking for hearty comfort, make sure to try the chili and sweet potato fries, both of which received high praise from Chris Karner. Meanwhile, robust portions of cheese curds and expertly seasoned fish dishes will satisfy even the heartiest of appetites, as noted by satisfied patrons like Sharon B.
In addition to the food, the stunning views of the water serve as a picturesque backdrop to an already delightful experience. It’s the perfect setting to savor each bite while enjoying the vibrant Bayfield environment.
With an inviting atmosphere, attentive service, and a menu full of delightful offerings, The Pickled Herring is undoubtedly a must-visit destination for anyone traveling through Bayfield. Whether you’re indulging in adventurous dishes like sautéed fish livers or simply enjoying a craft cocktail, every visit promises a memorable culinary journey. Don’t just take our word for it—experience the warmth and flavors yourself!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Truly gluten free! Staff changes gloves and washes hands between foods and offer a gluten free bun, (additional charge). Just make sure to specify that you need gluten free food if you do. Staff are very heart warming and hospitable and attended us throughout the entire meal. The cuisine tasted amazing and fresh. I would definitely recommend stopping here to eat if you’re in the area. ”
“ Beautiful bar and great view of the water. Had the chili and sweet potato fries and both were delicious! Service from our bartender Ashley was awesome! ”
“ My boyfriend and I came to The Pickled Herring for the first time after coming to Bayfield for the third time in the winter. Every cocktail was AMAZING! We had to take a picture of the menu so we could attempt to re create them at home. We had the Steak Naan for an appetizer and that could have been an entree . It was so delicious. Jody is a great bartender, he knows everything about the bar, restaurant and the city. We will be back every visit! Thank you for the wonderful experience, Jody! ”
“ If you're adventurous try the fish livers. Sauteed with onion and peppers. YUM ”
“ Delicious food, great service! Portions are large, come hungry! Cheese curds were so good. Fish & sweet potatoes were very good. ”
“ Can’t say enough about the food! The blackened whitefish and homemade “chips” with homemade mild horseradish sauce ... OMG! Great service, nice atmosphere; clean and music at a level that you can hold a conversation easily. I’ll be back! ”
“ We decided to visit this restaurant based on the reviews. It's also across the street from the Apostle Island Cruise we took. I ordered the whitefish and fries because I heard that whitefish is good. It was delicious...so flakey and tender. I also tried cheese curds for the first time. They were good even though I'm not really into fried cheese. I highly recommend and will definitely return. ”
“ Visited the Pickled Herring for a late lunch/early dinner before an Apostle Islands cruise, since it was right across the street from the docks and rated pretty well. It's definitely a fun place to relax and have a drink or a full meal. I ordered the Hugo Spritz and it was exactly what I was looking for in a cocktail....light and crisp. I ordered the fish sandwich so I could try the local Lake Superior white fish. Blackened was a good choice for how it was cooked. Flaky and juicy...delicious. ibopted for the sweet potato wedges as a side, and wow, were they good and a generous serving. I think I ate the equivalent of two medium sweet potatoes in one sitting...lol. everything tasted great and the staff were very friendly. The dinner seating overlooks Lake Superior, always a plus, and their bar area looks like a fun vibe, too. I would come back. Thanks! ”